12 Fancy PB&J Recipes That Are All-Grown-Up (2024)

01of 12

Peanut Butter & Pomegranate

12 Fancy PB&J Recipes That Are All-Grown-Up (1)

Ditch your sugary jelly or jam for fresh pomegranate with this healthy Grilled Peanut Butter and Pomegranate recipe. Made with sprouted bread, coconut oil, and pomegranate seeds, it's essentially a superfood sandwich that tastes like childhood.

02of 12

Grilled PB&J with Bacon, Apple, and Pomegranate

12 Fancy PB&J Recipes That Are All-Grown-Up (2)

In case you thought peanut butter and jelly were a good combo, just wait until you add apple, bacon, and pomegranate like in this loaded Grilled PB&J. Crunchy apples plus salty bacon, sweet jam, creamy peanut butter, and tart pomegranate seeds equals pure happiness (and a whole lot of flavors and textures). Even your fave Skippy & Smuckers from elementary school can't live up to this.

03of 12

Peanut Butter & Strawberry Quesadilla

12 Fancy PB&J Recipes That Are All-Grown-Up (3)

Forget the bread and reach for a tortilla instead; these PB&J Quesadillas also pack strawberry and banana slices to beef up the bite. To sweeten it up for dessert, you can even add a sprinkle of chocolate chips or drizzle of honey.

Sunflower Seed Butter, Banana, and Blueberry Vanilla Chia Seed Jam

12 Fancy PB&J Recipes That Are All-Grown-Up (4)

DIY your own Blueberry Vanilla Chia Seed Jam with just blueberries, maple syrup, chia seeds, and vanilla extract. Spread on an English muffin (or any bread of choice) with sunflower seed butter and banana slices, and you have a drool-worthy breakfast that seems (and tastes!) so much fancier than straight-up PB&J on Wonderbread.

05of 12

Grilled Peanut Butter & Jelly with Brie

12 Fancy PB&J Recipes That Are All-Grown-Up (5)

Are your tastebuds prepared for the most epic sandwich mashup ever? Think: grilled cheese plus PB&J. Making this Grilled Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich with Brie is as easy as it sounds: Spread the jam and nut butter, top with sliced brie, and grill until gooey. The ultimate adult comfort food, served up sandwich-style.

06of 12

Ultimate Strawberry PB&J

12 Fancy PB&J Recipes That Are All-Grown-Up (6)

Make it a double-decker: This Ultimate Strawberry PB&J has three layers of bread, strawberry preserves, and peanut butter as well as sliced strawberries and a sprinkle of whole unsalted peanuts to add a satisfying crunch.

Peanut Butter & Rhubarb Jelly French Toast Sandwich

12 Fancy PB&J Recipes That Are All-Grown-Up (7)

Homemade rhubarb jelly and French toasted bread take this Peanut Butter and Jelly Hot Sandwich to the next level. Top with a bit of powdered sugar and enjoy with either your hands or a fork and knife—there's no wrong way to eat it, as long as you don't leave a single crumb behind.

08of 12

Almond Butter & Jam with Homemade Bread

12 Fancy PB&J Recipes That Are All-Grown-Up (8)

Time to really adult-ify this classic sandwich: just use homemade bread and DIY almond butter. To make this Almond Butter & Jam Sandwich, you should whip up your own loaf of vegan, gluten-free bread and homemade salted almond butter (we promise, they're both easier than they sound!).

09of 12

Grilled Peanut Butter & Mango Peach Sandwich

12 Fancy PB&J Recipes That Are All-Grown-Up (9)

Blueberries, strawberries, and raspberries? Boring. Try topping your peanut butter with topical mango and juicy peach slices in this Grilled Peanut Butter & Mango Peach Sandwich. Add a drizzle of honey on top for an extra dash of sweetness and these five health benefits (but be warned—it makes it messy).

10of 12

Fig, Peanut Butter, & Honey Toast

12 Fancy PB&J Recipes That Are All-Grown-Up (10)

To be fair, this is technically toast and not a sandwich. But if you're hungry, why not just slap two of these toasts together? With fresh Fig, Peanut Butter, and Honey, you really can't go wrong. (If you like this, you'll love our honey sunflower avocado toast recipe from the Tone It Up girls.)

11of 12

PB&J Blueberry Crepes

12 Fancy PB&J Recipes That Are All-Grown-Up (11)

Who said a sandwich had to be on bread? These Peanut Butter and Jelly Crepes are a delicious, easy way to fancify your PB&J (because anything French is automatically fancy AF, right?). Just whip up some quick crepes using eggs, milk, flour, sugar, and salt, top with peaut butter, jelly, and a line of blueberries, and roll.

12of 12

PB&J Banana Pancake Sandwich

12 Fancy PB&J Recipes That Are All-Grown-Up (12)

If you're not a crepe fan and want some more oomph to your sandwich, make PB&J with Banana Pancakes instead. These whole wheat banana pancakes are full of fiber, and you can whip them up on the weekends for a healthy brunch. Use the leftovers for these sandwiches, and your weekday mornings (or lunches) will feel super indulgent.